While the discussion on the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) has predominantly revolved around laws on marriage, divorce, adoption, etc., its potential impact on legislation related to revenue and inheritance is equally significant. The Hindu family succession system and the tax benefits for a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) are likely to see the most direct effects. These concepts, unique to Hinduism, do not find parallels in other religions.

Read More

Hindu Undivided Family (HUF)

The question of whether UCC reforms would lead to the abolition of the Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) as a tax-exempt category looms large. Originating from the Hindu joint family system, the HUF enjoys a distinct tax structure, recognizing it as a separate legal entity, a privilege not extended to any other religious group.

Historically, concerns about revenue loss due to HUF’s special exemptions have been raised, with various committees post-Independence echoing similar sentiments. The Wanchoo Committee of 1971 highlighted the HUF’s role in tax avoidance, suggesting its abolition.

Despite these concerns, an HUF operates as a separate entity, holding its own PAN card and engaging in business or investments. It enjoys a basic tax exemption and other benefits under the Income Tax Act, raising questions about the fairness of such privileges.

With the UCC’s potential to redefine these tax structures, the government faces the challenge of addressing the financial and logistical implications for Hindu families, especially those in business.

Coparcenary and Succession

The Hindu Succession system’s concept of “coparcenary” grants an inherent right by birth to inherit a share of ancestral property. Significant strides towards gender equality were made with the 2005 amendment to the Hindu Succession Act, granting daughters equal rights to ancestral property, a stance further reinforced by the Supreme Court in 2020.

These developments underscore the need for codification and streamlining of succession laws across religions to ensure gender equality, highlighting discrepancies in Muslim Law and the need for clarity in Christian and Parsi succession laws.

Succession laws in other religions

The lack of codification in Muslim Law, ambiguities in the Indian Succession Act of 1925 applicable to Christians, and discriminatory provisions in Parsi succession laws call for comprehensive reforms to ensure equitable inheritance rights across religions.

Anomalies in Hindu Succession Act

Despite amendments aimed at promoting gender equality, the Hindu Succession Act still harbors anomalies, particularly affecting the distribution of inheritance among family members. The Law Commission of India has highlighted these issues, suggesting further reforms to address the complexities of the Joint Family system.

As the debate over the Uniform Civil Code continues, its potential to transform tax, revenue, family structure, and inheritance laws remains a critical area of focus. The government’s approach to these changes will be pivotal in shaping the future legal landscape.

Published By: Rishabh Sharma

Published On: Jun 29, 2023